Is organic(有机)food worth the higher price? It's the classic grocery store dilemma(两难困境). Shoppers want the healthiest food possible, but organic products usually cost much more than conventionally(传统地)grown food.Whether or not to buy organic is a personal decision, said Mike Von Massow, professor of Food Agriculture. Science won't give a clear-cut(明确)answer to the question of whether organic food is "better". There are often trade-offs(权衡,取舍) and answers become less definitive depending on the product under consideration.One thing is definitive: Organic and conventionally grown food are equally nutritious(有营养). From a nutrition point of view, there is no difference between organic and traditionally grown products.Organic products don't necessarily have fewer pesticides(杀虫剂) - in fact, they may have more. There is also no big difference between organic and non-organic products from a food-safety perspective. Even organic growers use pesticides; they just use ones derived from natural sources. Both kinds of food meet official safety standards.Organic farming does have environmental benefits. It tends to do less harm to soil, wildlife and local ecosystems(生态系统) than conventional farming with synthetic chemicals. But organic farming has a major downside: it is less land-efficient. To produce the same quantity of crops, organic farming requires more farmland.Advocates argue that yields(产量) and efficiency of organic farming can be greatly improved with more research and investment. They believe organic methods can be scaled up to feed more people in the future.问题: What is the classic grocery store dilemma?A Whether or not one should eat organic food.B One wants the best food but their budget is limited.C Organic food costs more but it certainly tastes better.D Whether or not one can stretch their wallet far.
题目解答
答案
根据图片中的文章内容,我们来逐步分析并解答这个问题。
1. 定位关键信息
题目问的是:“What is the classic grocery store dilemma?”(经典的杂货店困境是什么?)
我们需要阅读文章的第一段来寻找答案。第一段写道:
> "Is organic(有机①)food worth the higher price? It's the classic grocery store dilemma(两难困境). Shoppers want the healthiest food possible, but organic products usually cost much more than conventionally(传统地)grown food."
这段话的意思是:有机食品是否值得更高的价格?这就是经典的杂货店困境。购物者想要尽可能健康的食物,但有机产品通常比传统种植的食物贵得多。
2. 分析“困境”的核心
这里的“dilemma”(两难困境)指的是消费者在购物时面临的一个矛盾:
- 一方面:消费者希望买到最健康(最好)的食物(即有机食品)。
- 另一方面:有机食品的价格更高,而消费者的预算(钱包)是有限的。
因此,这个困境的本质是在“追求最佳/最健康的食物”和“有限的预算”之间做出权衡。
3. 逐一分析选项
-
A. Whether or not one should eat organic food. (一个人是否应该吃有机食品。)
这个选项提到了是否吃有机食品,但它没有明确指出导致这种两难境地的根本原因——即“价格/预算”与“健康/质量”之间的冲突。它只是困境的结果,而不是困境本身的完整描述。 -
B. One wants the best food but their budget is limited. (一个人想要最好的食物,但他们的预算有限。)
这个选项完美地概括了第一段中提到的矛盾:购物者想要最健康的食物(the healthiest food possible / the best),但有机产品更贵(cost much more),这就隐含了预算的限制。这正是消费者在杂货店面临的两难选择。 -
C. Organic food costs more but it certainly tastes better. (有机食品更贵,但肯定味道更好。)
文章中并没有提到有机食品味道更好。事实上,第三段明确指出从营养角度看两者没有区别,第四段说在食品安全方面也没有大差别。所以这个选项是错误的。 -
D. Whether or not one can stretch their wallet far. (一个人是否能把钱花得很值/让钱包撑得远。)
这个选项只关注了预算(钱包)方面,没有提及消费者想要“最好食物”的愿望,因此它只涵盖了困境的一半,不够全面。
结论
通过对比,选项 B 最准确地描述了第一段中提到的“经典的杂货店困境”:消费者既想要最好的(健康的)食物,又受到预算(更高价格)的限制。
正确答案是:B
解析
本题考查对文章细节信息的理解。解题思路是先在文章中找到与“classic grocery store dilemma”相关的描述,明确其核心矛盾,再将各选项与该核心矛盾进行对比分析。
- 首先在文章第一段找到关键信息:“Is organic(有机)food worth the higher price? It's the classic grocery store dilemma(两难困境). Shoppers want the healthiest food possible, but organic products usually cost much more than conventionally(传统地)grown food.” 这表明经典的杂货店困境是消费者想要尽可能健康的食物,但有机产品价格更高。
- 接着分析各选项:
- A选项 “Whether or not one should eat organic food.” 只提到是否吃有机食品,未体现出价格与健康之间的冲突,不是困境的完整描述,所以A选项错误。
- B选项 “One wants the best food but their budget is limited.” 准确概括了消费者想要最健康(最好)的食物,却因有机产品价格高而受预算限制的矛盾,与文章中描述的困境一致,所以B选项正确。
- C选项 “Organic food costs more but it certainly tastes better.” 文章中未提及有机食品味道更好,所以C选项错误。
- D选项 “Whether or not one can stretch their wallet far.” 只关注预算方面,未提及消费者想要“最好食物”的愿望,不全面,所以D选项错误。